In Defense of the Reasonable Request
Requests, resentment, and autonomy in nonmonogamous relationships.
Requests, resentment, and autonomy in nonmonogamous relationships.

A couple of winters ago, a storm rolled across half the country and grounded flights for days. I was stuck out of state. Earlier that week, my partner had connected with someone at a party, hooked up on their first date a couple days later, and then they talked about hanging out again a few days later. The night of my return was one of the nights in play. We’d planned to reconnect on Friday night, before a potential second date of theirs on Saturday or Sunday, but the FAA had other plans.
“Babe, can I have Saturday?”
I made a request. We’re careful not to exercise veto power in our relationship, nor do we try to dictate the specifics of each other’s plans with other partners. Winter weather had placed my time with my partner in direct conflict with loose discussions of plans between my partner and this new person.
I wasn’t making demands, and this was a nuanced situation with a few different considerations at play. I was returning to town to see my partner after some time away. And I was craving reconnection after he’d hooked up with someone new. In this case, the plans we’d had to see each other as soon as Friday were no longer on the table. I had mixed feelings about bumping this new person out of the next available time slot.

Photo by Oziel Gomez
Before I made the ask to plant my flag in Saturday night I had to assess my motives. Was part of me reaching for control? Was this me inhibiting their connection? Was it an ask to reconnect and get some reassurance? Or was it both and/or all things?
When a partner makes a request, like:
Would you mind moving Friday to Thursday?
Could you hold off on seeing her this weekend?
Can we slow things down with him, just for a little while?
These are often fair requests. Someone who loves you is trying to take care of themselves inside something you’re building together, and asks like this can be one of the more courageous ways to do that. But when you’re on the receiving end of that request, you might feel a little pang of resistance. An awareness of the tension between caring for your partner and protecting something of your own, while also accounting for another person in the mix too.
The partner asking is often bracing too. They’re unsure whether they’re allowed to need anything at all, and worried that the asking itself means they’re controlling.
Both and all things can be true. And parsing what’s “fair” or how you might proceed is - you guessed it - nuanced and complicated.
Many couples new to nonmongamy that I’ve worked with have struggled with exactly this tension. Let’s work with an example, and let’s call these fictional lovers Tai and Dani.
A few months ago, Tai started seeing someone new. It’s going well. It’s the kind of new connection that gives you a little pep in your step, where Tai all but squeals every time this new partner’s name lights up his cell phone. He’s high on NRE and, by his own description, he’s really excited and happy in this new connection.
Around the same time, Dani lost her job. It was a round of layoffs and she saw it coming, but it still really knocked her sideways. As an accomplished professional, her work means a lot to her. She’s been home a lot, sending out applications, waiting to hear back, trying to find constructive ways to busy herself otherwise, trying not to spiral.
Either of these situations would be challenging but manageable on their own. Together, there’s compounded tension and circumstances that make everything harder. Dani wants more of Tai right now: more presence, more support, a steady sense of partnership when other things feel unsteady. Tai wants to show up for her. He also wants to keep seeing his new partner, and he’s acutely aware that partner’s feelings are involved too. Also that new connections are delicate. A few canceled dates in the early weeks can define something before anyone has had a chance to fully explore.
So when Dani asked him to hold off on an overnight with his new partner, just until she felt a little steadier, Tai felt that flash of resistance. Alongside his genuine desire to be considerate, there’s a blend of a little indignation and righteousness too. (“I was very generous and understanding when Dani was hot and heavy with her new partner last year!”)
Part of what comes into play here is history. In Tai’s last relationship, requests were delivered as demands, and saying no came at a cost. His nervous system learned to hear any ask as the first step toward losing himself. For Tai, nonmonogamy has, in part, been a way of reclaiming that - of finally getting to live his relationships on his own terms.
For Dani, asking was its own small act of courage. She hates feeling like the “needy” partner. She’s spent much of her life minimizing what she needs so no one would think she’s “too much”, and she knew her request would put a damper on Tai’s excitement. She didn’t want to be the kind of partner who trampled his joy. But she couldn’t pretend she was fine, because she wasn’t. Pretending would only harden into resentment later, or into the kind of quiet distance that subtly wears a relationship down.
So we’ve got ourselves a chicken/egg scenario. If Tai bristles and refuses on principle, he confirms what Dani fears: that her feelings are an imposition and she shouldn’t have asked. If Dani’s requests build up too much over time (say if one weekend becomes a month and then an open-ended pause) she confirms what Tai fears: that her requests are really just an attempt to control.
Each of them has the power to soothe or to aggravate the other’s wound. So the work needs to happen on both sides of the dynamic. Progress and growth requires mutual generosity, with each partner tending to their own reactivity so the other isn’t held responsible for it.
A quick reminder on terms: agreements are co-created and revisited as things evolve; demands don’t really offer “no” as an option; requests allow room for a no, or a counteroffer.
Dani made a request. Tai, given his history, heard something closer to a demand. And my “Babe, can I have Saturday?” was a request made inside an agreement we already share: no vetoes, no dictating each other’s plans, no power exploitation leveraged against other partners. That agreement is part of why the ask felt loaded to me. I knew I was waking up to the edge.
And then there’s this controversial word that we sometimes use when our partners make a request: “freedom.” One of the most loaded words in the nonmonogamy lexicon after “hierarchy.”
Many of us chose nonmonogamy as a means to avoid control, possessiveness, scripted conventions, love and connection as scarce resources - to escape the problematic narrative that loving someone means owning their time and body. “Freedom” became the antidote and it is almost politically charged namely because it is an unattainable concept. We all live under capitalism. We have to work - individually and collectively - for our safety, food, and shelter. Which means navigating other people and being in relationship in many different forms. There is an idealized idea of what “freedom” means that simply doesn’t exist. Nor do I, personally, particularly crave that romanticized ideal. Because I want to care for my partners and receive care in kind. And that often means I don’t get to do “whatever I want” from moment to moment.
“You’re impeding on my freedom.” “We agreed no one gets to control anyone.” “I was generous when it was your turn.” Each of these statements can have some truth in it, but I’ve noticed they tend to show up at particular moments - when we’re trying to win an argument. Or as a means of avoiding the discomfort of a partner’s feelings. Crying “freedom” is often an attempt to end the discussion, rather than effort towards mutual care and understanding. Leveraging a “need for freedom” puts a layer of principle between us. Which insulates us from the discomfort of feeling responsible for our partner’s difficult feelings.
Tai’s flash of indignation was a version of this. His “I was very generous when Dani was hot and heavy last year” sounds like an argument for fairness. Underneath, it was also a way to avoid sitting with how frightened and unmoored Dani felt, and with how much he didn’t want her fear to cost him anything.
Which is why many of us seasoned NM peeps and practitioners use “autonomy” over “freedom.” Autonomy means ownership over our own choices. It doesn’t pretend that nothing can affect me, or that I’m not inclined to care about the impact my actions have on my partner(s). A freely chosen yes is an act of autonomy. So is a thoughtful no, or “how about this instead?”
Now, none of this means every request should be honored. Some requests are control framed within vulnerable language. And it’s hard to tell the difference, from both sides of the ask. When I’m the one making a request or the one receiving it, these are the questions I use:
Original Post: Laura Ramadei
Scan to download
Comments
Join the conversation — create a free account to comment.
Join the conversationLoading comments…