Non-Monogamy Hub
Join the conversationJoin
FEATURED

A Jealous Ex Read My Texts. It Taught Me What Loyalty Isn’t.

Why so much of what we call loyalty is really obedience, and what non-monogamy taught me about the real thing.

✦ BY LUNA ROSE
NOVEMBER 17, 2026
A Jealous Ex Read My Texts. It Taught Me What Loyalty Isn’t.

Photo by Sinead Michaela du Plessis

Years ago, before non-monogamy, I was in a monogamous relationship and had a close male friend I texted with fairly often. We sent each other memes, complained about school, and made plans to get coffee. If I’m honest, I was a little flirty with him sometimes, in the playful way you can be with someone you enjoy. But it was never something I considered acting on. I knew where the line was, and I had no intention of crossing it.

Then one day I found out my partner had been reading those texts, and he was upset. Not about anything I’d done, but about how I’d said things. I was using exclamation points. I was using smiley faces. To him, that punctuation was evidence that I was being too warm with someone who wasn’t him.

I remember sitting with that for a long time afterward. Maybe there was a little spark in those messages, but nothing in my behavior had been disloyal, and yet I’d somehow become disloyal anyway, and the proof was a “:)”. What he wanted, I think, was for me to be a little colder with everyone else, so that he could feel sure of where my warmth was going. And for a while I gave him that. I typed more carefully. I left off the exclamation points. I made myself slightly smaller so he wouldn’t feel threatened.

It took me years to see that what we were both calling loyalty was really something else.

What We Usually Mean by Loyalty

Most of us grew up with a very specific picture of a loyal partner. They don’t look at anyone else. They don’t have close friendships that might be confusing. They don’t flirt, don’t wonder, don’t want, or at least never let you see it. Loyalty, in this version, is a kind of containment. The more closed off someone’s inner life is, the more loyal they’re considered.

And yet the same culture has a strange exception built in. Before many weddings, there’s the bachelor or bachelorette party, where lap dances, strippers and a night of flirting with strangers are suddenly fine, even expected, as long as it’s a “last night of freedom.” It’s always struck me as odd. If those things really were betrayals, a party wouldn’t make them okay. And if they’re okay for one night, it’s hard to argue they’re the heart of what makes someone loyal. The pass makes it obvious that what we’re following isn’t a deep moral truth, but a set of social rules, complete with their own approved exceptions.

That picture is so familiar that it rarely gets questioned. But if you look at it closely, it describes compliance more than it describes devotion. It’s about following a set of rules, many of them unspoken, and being rewarded for how well you follow them. And when you follow rules because you’re afraid of what will happen if you don’t, that isn’t really loyalty. In my opinion, it’s closer to obedience.

Why the Difference Matters

From the outside, obedience and loyalty can look almost the same, which is why they’re so easy to confuse. The difference is where they come from. Obedience comes from restriction, the feeling that you’re not allowed to do otherwise. Loyalty comes from choice, and it only really counts when you could choose differently and don’t.

Over time, the difference starts to show. Obedience tends to breed resentment, because the person giving it keeps score of everything they’ve given up. It’s also easy to mistake following the rules for being faithful, when real faithfulness is harder: being honest when it costs you something, or standing up for your partner when they’re not in the room. Someone can follow every rule and still be absent in all the ways that matter, while someone who breaks every cultural rule can still be deeply, reliably loyal.

What Non-Monogamy Taught Me About It

When my partner and I opened up, a lot of the usual markers of loyalty disappeared overnight. We were allowed to look, to flirt, to date, to fall for people. If loyalty really meant what I’d been taught it meant, we should have had none left.

What I found instead was that I could finally see what loyalty actually was, because it couldn’t hide behind restriction anymore. It looked like my partner telling me the truth about how they felt, about a person or a situation, even when it was uncomfortable to say, rather than burying it and letting it come out later in a worse way.

It looked like them protecting our time together when something more exciting was on offer. It looked like the way they talk about me to the people they date, with respect, and without ever making me the problem in our relationship. None of that was enforced by a rule. It was given freely, again and again, and that’s exactly what made it mean something.

And it goes both ways. My current partner has never read my messages. They don’t need to. When I like someone, I tell them, usually before anything has even happened, and they ask about it with curiosity rather than suspicion (sometimes they even cheer me on). They aren’t threatened by my warmth toward other people, because they are secure in our love and commitment. And I offer that honesty freely, because I know it won’t be used against me.

The difference between those two relationships still amazes me. In the first one, I was given rules, and I followed them, and neither of us felt any safer. In the second, there are way fewer restrictions, and I’ve never felt more trusted or more committed. I don’t stay because I’m not allowed to leave. I stay because, with every option available to me, this is still where I want to be.

A Question for Monogamous Readers

None of this is an argument that monogamy is always focused on obedience. Monogamy chosen freely, by two people who’ve actually talked about what they want, can be one of the most loyal commitments there is. The question isn’t which structure you live in. It’s where your loyalty is coming from.

So it’s worth asking yourself, and maybe your partner: is your faithfulness something you’re choosing, or something you’re following? Is your partner’s loyalty measured by what they do for you, or only by what they don’t do? Do you feel trusted, or watched?

I know these are uncomfortable questions, but the answers say a lot about whether a relationship is held together by choice or by fear.

What Loyalty Actually Looks Like

Loyalty isn’t measured by what someone gives up for you. It’s measured by what they give you: the truth when it’s uncomfortable, their presence when things are hard, their respect when you’re not around to hear it, and the way they keep choosing you, day after day, simply because they want to.

You can’t make someone loyal. You can only create a relationship where loyalty feels safe to give. And in my experience, the more freedom you offer, the more of it comes back to you.


What does loyalty look like in your relationship? I’d love to hear in the comments.

If you’re curious how this works in practice for us, I shared the exact agreements my partner and I live by, including what we threw out along the way, with paid subscribers.

xx, Luna Rose

Original Post: Non-Monogamy Journal

Comments

Join the conversation — create a free account to comment.

Join the conversation

Loading comments…

Scan to download

Scan to download