When “We Tell Each Other Everything” Stops Working

There’s a particular kind of intimacy many monogamous couples take pride in: the sense that nothing is withheld. You probably know all of the intimate details of each other’s inner worlds and closest relationships. From parents to friends to colleagues, any friction or impactful moments with people outside the primary unit likely has historically been processed together first and foremost.

This level of openness often feels like safety, closeness, and best friendship. Sharing everything signals: I have nothing to hide. You are my person who I trust with everything. There are no secrets between us.

And in many monogamous dynamics, it works beautifully.

But if the relationship opens, that unfiltered, off the cuff sharing? Not so fast, my friend…

When it comes to processing new emotional or sexual connections, casually dropping potentially surprising information like “oh and by the way, we kissed” is rarely well received. Not because your partner doesn’t actually want you to have cute new connective experiences. But when tender information lands abruptly like that, the body often experiences it as an uncomfortable shock. Your partner may very well react strongly to surprise disclosures like this. Most people’s nervous systems need far more caretaking as they stretch into this new relationship territory.

In the early days of non-monogamy, when sharing about intimacy with others is still new, it can help to lean on what I call the three C’s: conscientiousness, consent, and containment.

What I mean by that is:

• Schedule intentional containers for processing (scheduled check-ins and time-limited conversations reduce surprise and exhaustion)

• Be intentional about the timing of when you share information about others (it’s usually much better received when you start a tender conversation with reassurance so you’re already feeling warm and connected to your partner).

• Draw new disclosure boundaries to keep the new structure feeling steady (decide what kind of information is actually helpful to hear vs. what information overwhelms your partner; slowly divulge data about your connection with others and modify how much more to share depending on your partner’s capacity)

For many people, not sharing everything immediately registers as distance, secrecy, or a sign that something is wrong. It can also carry grief for the simplicity of how closeness once felt.

But I can’t emphasize this enough: be discerning about how, what, and when you share with existing partner(s) about your experiences and feelings with others, and approach conversations about non-monogamy with care, intention, and as much spaciousness as you can muster while you build the capacity to truly hear one another.

Conversation by Camille Pissarro

Because once attachment is activated, (especially if you’ve just returned from a date with someone else), the felt sense of security in the more established bond begins to matter more than total transparency about the new connection. It’s worth clarifying: I’m not advocating for lying or omission; instead I’m strongly recommending choosing your words carefully and wrapping them with lots of reassurance. When a body is already bracing and scanning for threat, it may not be regulated enough to receive the full truth in real time. Slowness, pacing and skillful disclosures matter more than most people expect in the first several years of practicing non-monogamy.

As couples navigate this transition from monogamy to any form of openness, there are three communication patterns I observe over and over again. They arise from a genuine desire to stay connected and reduce uncertainty. Yet without realizing it, these patterns often increase nervous system activation and make connection feel more fragile rather than more secure.

Read more

Comments

Join the conversation — create a free account to comment.

Join the conversation

Loading comments…