The Conversation People Wait Too Long to Have in Non-Monogamy

You’re invited: Join me online next week for my free Week of Visibility for Non-Monogamy community meet & greet!

Giulio Aristide Sartorio, The Reading (Catullus and Clodia)

I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve sat with a couple where one partner says, ‘It was just coffee,’ and the other looks completely shattered.

The person sharing is confused.

The person receiving the news feels blindsided and overwhelmed. Sometimes they're crying.

Neither of them understands how they ended up in such different realities.

More often than not, the answer has very little to do with the coffee date itself.

Imagine Yasmin (she/her) is in a committed, nesting relationship with Wren (they/them). They've been practicing non-monogamy for several years and both support one another dating independently.

A few weeks ago, Yasmin met Savannah (she/they), who she thought was cute, interesting, fun to talk to. Meeting this new person didn’t seem important enough to mention to Wren.

A few days later, Yasmin realizes she’s still thinking about Savannah. She wonders what this person is like outside the context where they met. Maybe Yasmin looks them up on social media. Eventually they’re messaging. The conversation is flowing. She finds herself increasingly curious about where the connection might lead.

Still, she doesn’t bring it up.

Partly because she doesn’t know whether the interest is mutual. Partly because she’s still figuring out if she wants to pursue something with Savannah. But mostly because she’s not yet convinced there’s anything important to share with Wren yet.

Then one day, Savannah asks Yasmin if she’d like to get coffee.

Yasmin says yes.

And when she finally mentions it to Wren, it feels like a relatively small disclosure.

“It’s just coffee.”

But from Wren’s perspective, they’re hearing about the attraction, the curiosity, the messaging, the growing interest, and the upcoming date all at the same time. They feel blindsided, even when no agreements have been broken.

What feels like a small update to Yasmin feels like a fully formed story to Wren.

Many people in non-monogamy aren't actually struggling with attraction itself. They're struggling with informational asymmetry: one person has been living with a developing story for weeks while the other is encountering the entire story all at once. Often the rupture isn't the crush. It's the difference in timelines.

I’ve had moments in my own relationships where I delayed sharing an attraction because I didn’t want to create anxiety over something that might amount to nothing.

What I’ve learned is that by the time I finally shared, I had often already had weeks to orient to the experience, while partner was encountering it for the very first time.

Why We Wait

Just because someone has agreed to practice non-monogamy doesn’t mean they’ve learned how to talk openly about attraction to other people.

Monogamous culture trains us to conceal attraction. Most of us have very little practice saying things like:

“I think I might have a crush.”

“I’m curious about someone.”

“I find myself wanting to get to know them.”

Those conversations can bring up guilt, shame, fear of hurting someone we love, or fear of creating unnecessary anxiety.

So people wait.

The logic usually sounds reasonable:

“I don’t even know if this is real yet.”

“What if nothing comes of it?”

“Why bring it up if I don’t know whether they like me back?”

“I’ll tell my partner once I know more.”

Most people are genuinely trying to be considerate. They’re hoping to spare their partner unnecessary worry. What they are often surprised to discover is that waiting makes the eventual conversation feel larger, faster, and harder to absorb.

Sometimes waiting is about protecting ourselves from having to tolerate our partner’s feelings while we’re still making sense of our own.

The challenge in non-monogamy isn’t deciding whether attraction should be private or public.

It’s learning how to remain transparent before we have certainty.

Most of us want to wait until we understand what we’re feeling.

Our partners often want to be included while we’re still figuring it out. The longer we wait for clarity, the more compressed the eventual disclosure becomes.

Most people believe waiting protects their partner.

In my experience, waiting often makes these conversations much harder to navigate.

Because nervous systems tend to struggle far more with compressed information than gradual inclusion.

Read more

Comments

Join the conversation — create a free account to comment.

Join the conversation

Loading comments…